Discussion about this post

User's avatar
Osteoporosis Research's avatar

Appreciated how directly you laid out the mortality data. The LIFTMOR numbers are the ones I keep coming back to: a 2.9 percent lumbar spine gain against a 1.2 percent loss in controls, from eight months of training at over 85 percent of one rep max, with no vertebral fractures from the loading. Watson et al. (JBMR 2018) ran that protocol in postmenopausal women with low bone mass, including diagnosed osteoporosis, using deadlift, squat, overhead press and jumping chin-ups. That safety record directly undercuts the fear that keeps many people with osteoporosis on light bands forever.

One practical caveat worth adding from the research side: those adherence and safety numbers came with trained supervision in small groups. Home-grown heavy lifting is not the same intervention, and coaching quality around a fragile spine is most of the difference. So the takeaway is less "start lifting heavy" and more "start lifting heavy under someone who knows how to coach older adults."

One question for you. You rank walking below true resistance loading, which the trial data supports. But cohort data still ties regular walking to lower hip fracture risk. Is that mostly a balance and fitness effect rather than a bone effect, in your read?

- Moses

No posts

Ready for more?